Taj Mahal Controversy: Is Newly Filed RTI Request Regarding Claims that Taj Mahal Is a Hindu Temple?

Taj Mahal Controversy: Is Newly Filed RTI Request Regarding Claims that Taj Mahal Is a Hindu Temple?

The ivory-white marble mausoleum of the Taj Mahal Crown of the Palace in Agra, India, sits on the Yamuna River’s right bank. One of Shah Jahan’s most beloved wives, Mumtaz Mahal, was buried at the mausoleum in 1632;

Shah Jahan also rests in the mausoleum. For being “the pearl of Muslim art in India and one of the globally acclaimed masterpieces of the world’s heritage,” the Taj Mahal was declared a UNESCO World Heritage Site in 1983.

Mughal architecture at its finest, it’s considered by many to be a sign of India’s rich heritage. Moreover, 6 million people visit the Taj Mahal each year, and it was named one of the New 7 Wonders of the World (2000–2007) in 2007.

Who Was the Architect and When Was the Taj Mahal Built?

After Babur, Humayun, Akbar, and Jahangir, Shah Jahan was the fifth Mughal emperor. As one of the greatest Mughals, he has been dubbed the “Golden Age of Mughals.” In his lifetime, Shah Jahan built a number of magnificent structures,


including the Taj Mahal in Agra, the most famous of which. The Taj Mahal Complex was built in 1631 AD. As of 1648 AD, the main tomb had been completed, while the outlying buildings and gardens had been completed five years later in 1653 AD.

Did Shah Jahan Mutilate the Taj Mahal’s Construction Workers’ Fingers?

Urban legend has it that Shah Jahan cut the hands of the Taj Mahal’s builders. For the workmen who helped build the Taj Mahal, Shah Jahan built a large town named Taj Ganj. Today, the settlement is still standing.

While the Emperor cared for his many workers, the accusation that he hacked off their hands stands out. This claim has been found to be a hoax in numerous studies. Moreover, there appears to be no basis for this assertion as well.

How Did the Controversy About the Taj Mahal Begin?

PN Oak, a self-styled historian, claimed in a book published in 2018 that the Taj Mahal’s Hindu origins were evidenced in his work, according to an ASI official who spoke to India Today at the time.

Supporters of the ‘Tejo mahalay’ idea think there was an old, pre-Taj Mahal Shiva temple that Shah Jahan supposedly used to bury his wife Mumtaz in the temple’s “Sanctum Sanctorum,” which is located at that location.


Nevertheless, the ASI informed the Agra court in 2017 that there was no evidence to show that the structure ever contained a temple.

Controversy in The Present Day

The Allahabad High Court’s Lucknow bench received a plea last week asking to “discover the truth” about the Taj Mahal’s 22 closed rooms. Rajneesh Singh, the media coordinator for the BJP’s Ayodhya branch, brought the case. He was the one who filed it.

According to certain historians, the Taj Mahal is in fact a temple dedicated to the Hindu god Shiva. Archaeological surveys in India should appoint a special committee to study the sealed rooms and issue a report.

The Opinion of The Allahabad Supreme Court

There were no legal or constitutional rights infringed, the Allahabad High Court said on Thursday, May 12, according to the petitioner’s failure to point out this fact.

“casual” filing of the PIL by the petitioner’s lawyer was scolded by the Lucknow bench, which said it couldn’t rule on the subject under Article 226 of the Constitution.

“The historical investigation should use a good technique for the prayer regarding the opening of the rooms. This is something that historians should handle “On Thursday, the Supreme Court ruled.

The Petition Requested the Opening of 22 Doors of The Monument

An ASI, Agra, Agra, response acquired through the RTI Act stated that the Taj Mahal’s 22 rooms had been shut for “security reasons.” P N Oak (the author of Taj Mahal: The True Story) believes that the Shiva Temple is located in the upper and lower sections of the Taj Mahal, according to the petitioner.


On the Tejo Mahalaya claim, Oak asserts that the monument was created in 1155 AD. Supreme Court ruled in 2000 that the Taj Mahal was not built by a Hindu ruler, dismissing Oak’s petition to do so. We owned the land on which the Taj Mahal was built: a BJP lawmaker claims

According to Diya Kumari, the BJP Lok Sabha MP from Rajsamand and a descendant of the old Jaipur dynasty, the site on which the Taj Mahal was built belonged to her family. This land was once owned by the Jaipur Royal family, which was later taken over by Mughal emperor Shah Jahan. She also claimed to have paperwork to confirm this.

It was impossible for Jaipur’s royal family to resist Shah Jahan when he seized their country, Kumari added. “According to Jaipur Raj Parivaar Trust, all the land records are in their possession. The Royal family will provide the documents if the court mandates it “told reporters what he’d heard from his party’s MP.